One of the blogs which really got me to thinking about fat, body shape and healthy living irregardless of those first two; Shapely Prose; fairly recently had a post about new shirts available in their store of fat-positive clothing and knick-knacks.
In the comments thread for this post, folks were trying to offer up a slogan for a new shirt which would embody the spirit of HAES (Health At Every Size) and the idea of excersizing for fun and health, rather than to shed those extra pounds. The line I came up with, “I exercize to Move It, not to Lose It” received a general applause. The last few days, especially hearing the complaints of fellow co-workers who bemoan the need to run an extra mile or two to “work off” that piece of cake at lunch, I’ve been pondering this thought more and more. You might say that the need to write about this is what spurred my launch of this blog!
What it comes down to is simply this: your body is NOT some sort of fat or calorie teleportation device; not an abacus of weight gain/loss directly correlated to movement. Excercising until that elliptical machine shows “250 calories burned” does not somehow magically lift that 250 calorie slice of cake you ate and, for some reason, feel so damned guilty about, OUT of your body. Despite the pervasive “Common Knowledge” myth that 3,500 calories= 1 pound of weight, studies have shown the drastically increasing your activity, simply to lose weight, does not work (and may even have the reverse effect!).
So why are you exercising so hard, for so long, in a manner you HATE, in the vain attempt to somehow remove the guilt and the weight of having eaten something? Why not find an activity you LOVE to do and enjoy it for the simple pleasure it brings? Rather than count the calories burned or the heart rate reached, take time to feel the joy in what you are doing and the healthier body it might help develop?
Love swimming? Then feel the power of your muscles as you slice through the water across the pool. Marvel at how your body, that body you dismiss and feel disgust over for its small imperfections so often, manages to move you so fluidly. Don’t count the laps to ascertain how many calories you “burned”.
Enjoy running? Then feel the strength in your legs as you get up that next hill. Feel the wonder of your body moving in a solid pace and feel your lungs enjoy each breath. Don’t track each mile as another 200 calories you are “allowed” to now consume.
Me? I dance. I swim. I walk. All because I LOVE to! When I dance I amaze myself with the way my body can move; the way I can put in motion the feeling of a piece of music. When I swim I close my eyes and feel the water lapping over my skin, glorying in the strength of my muscles moving me along. And when I walk I look around and feel the ground beneath my feet and feel my lungs getting stronger. I know that my next session on my trumpet will have even more power thanks to my stronger breathing. Through it all, I just amaze at my wonderful body. This amazing, fat, powerful body; which not only gets me through the mundania of the regular movements required of it, but also manages to astound me every day with the other wonderous motions it can make. Not in any of those thoughts is the count of how many calories I’ve burned away and how much potential weight loss that might translate into.
So my advice to you? Find an activity you LOVE. I personally found that running an elliptical machine in the gym is not for me. However, dancing and swimming? Perfect! So, find what you love and are able to do, to whatever level you are capable. Then, do it. Exercise for fun, for strength, for the more powerful lungs and a lower-stress mind that it may bring. Don’t worry about reaching some weight goal or redeeming some snack by running another mile. Stop when you are tired and ready to rest. Your size does not matter (you CAN be fit and fat). Your level of ability does not matter. How you look while DOING it does not matter. Be kind to your body and just move for the love of Moving It! Not…for the love of Losing It.
June 26, 2008 at 10:40 am
[...] which has been tumbling around in my mind as I went to create this blog (aside from that of exercise for fun, not weight loss) was the concept of the society imposed morality….of food. “Good” foods (Which [...]
June 26, 2008 at 10:41 am
well said….interesting…and to the point…a good point…well done
June 26, 2008 at 11:25 am
I love it! Hi – this linked to one of my Move 2008 posts thanks to WordPress. My philosophy behind Move ‘08 was exactly that – just move and have fun with it. Dancing is one part of my aerobic routines too. So is walking. The closest thing I come to a ‘gym’ is the stationary bike I have, but I love using that while I watch tv so it doesn’t feel like work at all. I move because I spent a year being unintentionally sedentary and I felt it. I’m in my 40s so it is more heightened if you don’t move. For me, exercise has nothing to do with numbers on a scale, it is just about being heart healthy and fit and flexible and strong.
I love your outlook!
June 29, 2008 at 9:22 pm
“For me, exercise has nothing to do with numbers on a scale, it is just about being heart healthy and fit and flexible and strong. ”
Exactly my thoughts! Once you set aside the determination that movement is ONLY linked to an increase in calories you’re ALLOWED to eat; and just move to MOVE, it becomes a pleasure instead of a chore. It is so nice to just do the things I like to do instead of pushing myself to do things I hate because I felt I had to!
September 11, 2008 at 11:32 am
[...] for it. I already exercise; though it probably doesn’t “count” since I have FUN at the same time. I eat a tasty variety of foods in a quantity that fuels my body the way it [...]
September 15, 2008 at 2:10 pm
[...] CAN BE FUN. You do not have to run like a gerbil in a wheel for physical activity to [...]
January 8, 2009 at 9:52 am
[...] something, anything. And making the sorts of changes that a lot of Fat Acceptance proposes (doing exercise you like, learning to listen to your body and eat what you intuitively need, loving yourself as you are) are [...]
May 7, 2009 at 10:54 am
[...] to fool some honey bees) or to continue feeding his body the nutrients it needs and craves or to do exercises he LIKES to do. Being a fat bear does not mean Pooh is less loved by his woodland friends or his human [...]
May 13, 2009 at 8:58 am
[...] I’m not so much advocating for some sort of Wall-E-esque age when humans float around in self-contained entertainment chairs, oblivious to the world around them. Instead I’m suggesting that the idea of spending our body’s daily allotment of physical energy on better things; more interesting things; activities that (dare I say it?) may actually be ENJOYABLE or FUN. [...]
June 11, 2009 at 7:23 am
I know this is an old post, but I wanted to let you know that you moved me to tears. Because I have never been able to find an activity that I love, and I have spent many hours on activities I hate, this piece just touched me. Thank you.
(trying to find out how to rss feed you into my friends list…)
June 11, 2009 at 8:00 am
Nathreee while I’m certainly sorry to cause tears I’m really happy to have touched someone in a way that connects just how awful it is to use exercise to punish our bodies instead of moving just for the sake of moving in ways that we like.